How to get Google reviews, legally
What Google allows, and a request you can send.
SEO · Google reviews
How to respond to negative Google reviews
without making it worse.
A bad review is public, and so is your reply. This guide shows the reply Google’s own rules point to, which reviews you can report, what to do about extortion, what Maltese law adds, and a free builder that drafts the reply for you.
Short answer
Reply to a negative Google review within a day or two: thank the reviewer, own what was your fault, say what you changed and invite them to contact your business privately, in about five sentences. Report the review only if it breaks Google’s policies, such as fake, abusive or conflict-of-interest reviews, because Google does not remove reviews just for being negative. Review management is part of SEO in Malta at Malta Digital, from €997 a month.
Key takeaways
- Should I respond to negative Google reviews? Yes, in most cases. Your reply is public, the reviewer is notified, and future customers read it. A short, honest reply that says what you changed can persuade the next reader and may lead the reviewer to update their review. Google says you do not need to reply to every review, but negative ones are where a reply helps most.
- How do you respond to a negative Google review? Thank the reviewer, own the part that was your fault, explain briefly without excuses, say what you changed, and invite them to contact your business privately. Sign with your name. Keep it to about five sentences and never share their private details.
- Can I get a negative Google review removed? Only if it breaks Google’s policies, for example if it is fake, from a competitor or a former employee, abusive, off-topic or contains personal information. Report it from your Business Profile. Google says it does not remove reviews just because a business disagrees with them.
Why it matters
Your reply is written for the next customer.
A negative review on Google is not a private complaint. Your reply is posted publicly under the review, it shows as coming from your business, and Google tells the reviewer you have answered. Every person who checks you on Maps later reads both sides. A calm, specific reply often does more for your reputation than the review did against it.
Google’s own help pages say negative reviews “aren’t necessarily a sign of poor business practices” and that a good reply and follow-up “may even encourage the customer to update their review”. If they do update it, the review date changes to show the edit. That is the best outcome, and it only happens when the reply makes the customer feel heard.
Two practical details matter in Malta, where many businesses run their Google profile from a phone between jobs. You must have a verified Business Profile to reply at all, and Google checks every reply against its content policies before it goes up. That check usually takes up to 10 minutes but can take up to 30 days, so do not panic if your reply does not appear straight away. If you are still setting up, start with our Google Business Profile setup guide, then come back here.
First step
Decide: reply, report, or both.
Before you type anything, work out which of three situations you are in. Most negative reviews are from real customers with a real complaint, even if it is exaggerated. Those you answer and learn from. A few break Google’s rules: fake reviews, posts from former staff or rivals, abuse or private details. Those you report. And a small number are part of an extortion scam, where someone floods you with 1-star reviews and then asks for money to remove them. Those you never answer.
The common mistake is to treat every bad review as fake. Google is clear that you should not report a review just because you disagree with it, and that it “doesn’t get involved in conflict between businesses and customers”. Reporting a genuine complaint wastes your time and leaves the review unanswered while you wait. Check your bookings, orders or call log first. A restaurant in Valletta can usually match a review to a table and a date; a plumber in Mosta can match it to a job sheet.
How to write it
Five sentences that work.
Google’s tips for replies boil down to this: be polite, keep it short, be honest about mistakes, do not take the blame for things outside your control, apologise where it is right, and sign with your name. A reply that follows that pattern usually fits in five sentences.
| Part | What it does | Example |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Thank and name | Shows a person read it | “Hi Maria, thank you for taking the time to write this.” |
| 2. Own the part that was yours | Honest, specific | “A 40-minute wait for two coffees is not acceptable, and we are sorry.” |
| 3. Explain, without excuses | Context for future readers | “We were two staff short that Sunday and should have told you at the door.” |
| 4. Say what changed | Proof you listened | “We now add a third person on weekend mornings.” |
| 5. Offer a private route, and sign | Moves it offline | “If you would like to talk, email us at hello@yourcafe.mt. Daniel, owner.” |
The fourth line is the one most businesses skip, and it is the one that persuades the next reader. “We take all feedback seriously” says nothing. “We now add a third person on weekend mornings” says you fixed it. If you have not fixed anything yet, say what you are checking and when.
Google also lets businesses post their own business phone, email or social handles in a reply, so inviting the reviewer to contact you is allowed. Use the business contact only, never a staff member’s personal number. Where the problem was outside your control, Google’s own example is weather: you cannot stop a storm, but you can explain that you watch the forecast and send cancellation notices early. In Malta that covers rough seas cancelling a boat trip, a Gozo Channel delay, or a power cut on a summer evening.
What to avoid
Four things that make it worse.
Sharing private details. Never mention what the person ordered, when they booked, their address or anything from your records. Google’s policy bans posting personal information without consent, and personal data about your customers is also covered by the GDPR. “We have checked our records” is enough; the details stay inside the business.
Offering something to change the review. A discount, a free meal or a refund in exchange for editing or deleting a review is banned by Google, which removes reviews posted after such incentives. You can refund a customer because they deserve it. You cannot make the refund conditional on the review.
Arguing in public. Even when the reviewer is wrong, a point-by-point rebuttal reads as defensive to everyone else. State the facts once, briefly, and move the conversation offline. If you are angry, write the reply, wait an hour, and cut it in half.
Copy-paste replies. Google advises against sending the same thank-you to everyone and suggests focusing on reviews where you can add something useful. Identical replies under ten complaints look automated and suggest nobody read them.
Want your Google profile looked after properly every month? Apply now for SEO in Malta
Reportable or not
Which reviews Google will remove.
Google only removes reviews that break its Maps user-generated content policy. Being unfair, one-sided or harsh is not enough. The table below sums up the main categories from that policy and what you should do in each case.
| The review… | Breaks the policy? | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Is harsh but describes a real visit | No. Google allows negative experiences described respectfully | Reply and fix the problem |
| Is from a competitor, or a current or former employee | Yes, conflict of interest | Report it; reply briefly and neutrally |
| Is part of a sudden wave of similar reviews | Likely, rating manipulation | Report each one; if money is demanded, use the extortion form |
| Was bought, or given for a discount | Yes, incentivised | Report it (and never do this yourself) |
| Contains threats, hate speech or profanity | Yes | Report it; do not engage |
| Names a staff member’s private details or posts personal info | Yes, personal information | Report it |
| Accuses you of a crime without basis | Yes, “unsubstantiated allegations of unethical behaviour or criminal wrongdoing” | Report it; consider legal advice if it is serious |
| Is about a different business or is off-topic | Yes, off-topic | Report it; reply to point them to the right place |
Google also bans businesses from discouraging negative reviews or asking only happy customers to review. That matters when you plan how you collect reviews in the first place; our guide on how to get Google reviews shows a request you are allowed to send.
Reporting
How to report a review, and appeal once.
To report a review, open your Business Profile, select Read reviews, choose Report next to the review and pick the reason, such as spam or profanity. Google says the check usually takes several days. You can follow it in the Reviews Management Tool, which shows one of three statuses: decision pending, reviewed with no policy violation, or escalated.
If Google finds no violation and you disagree, you get one appeal. In the Reviews Management Tool choose the option to check reviews you reported, select Appeal eligible reviews, pick up to 10 reviews and fill in the form. You get the final decision by email. Use the appeal for clear cases with evidence, such as a review from a known former employee, not for reviews you simply dislike.
Two extra routes exist. In the Google Maps app you can report the reviewer’s whole profile if they post inappropriate content across many businesses. And if a review is unlawful, for example clearly defamatory, Google has a separate legal removal request form. That route needs you to explain the legal basis, which is where a Malta lawyer earns their fee.
Free tool
Draft your reply in a minute.
Pick the kind of review, add your business name and the contact you want people to use, and tick what applies. The builder drafts a short reply in the five-part pattern above and tells you whether to report the review as well. Always edit the middle sentence so it says what you actually changed.
Negative review reply builder
Built on Google Business Profile Help, read 10 November 2026. Nothing you type is sent anywhere.
Your reply
This builder needs JavaScript. The five-part pattern above works just as well by hand.
The drafts are starting points, not finished replies. A reply that mentions one specific detail from the review will always beat a template.
Extortion
If someone asks for money to remove reviews.
Google now has a dedicated page for “negative review extortion scams”. The pattern is a sudden wave of 1-star and 2-star reviews, followed by a message on WhatsApp, Telegram, email or social media offering to remove them for money, goods or services. Google’s advice is blunt: do not engage, do not pay, and do not try to fix it yourself by offering anything.
Instead, collect evidence straight away. Take screenshots of every demand showing the date, time and the sender’s number, email or profile. Copy the direct link to each suspicious review. Note when the reviews started and when the first demand arrived. Then send everything through Google’s merchant extortion report form. Google says it investigates and tells you the result, but it will not share the details of the investigation.
Extortion is also a crime, so you can report the demand to the Malta Police as well. Keep replying to your real customers as normal while it is investigated; a profile that keeps answering genuine reviews looks healthy to every reader.
Malta law
What Maltese law adds.
Fake reviews are illegal for businesses, not just against Google’s rules. Malta’s Consumer Affairs Act, as amended by Act XIII of 2022 to bring in the EU’s consumer “Omnibus” directive, lists as unfair commercial practices both submitting or commissioning false consumer reviews to promote products, and claiming reviews come from real customers without reasonable steps to check. Burying a bad review under bought five-star ones can break the law as well as Google’s policy.
Defamation is a civil matter. The Media and Defamation Act (Cap. 579) of 2018 abolished criminal libel in Malta. A statement is only defamatory if it causes, or is likely to cause, serious harm to reputation, and for a business that trades for profit, harm is not serious unless it causes or is likely to cause serious financial loss. Moral damages for libel are capped at €11,640. In practice, most harsh reviews are honest opinion about a real experience, and suing over them rarely makes sense. Speak to a lawyer before you threaten anyone, and never threaten legal action in a public reply.
Privacy law applies to your replies. If your reply reveals what a customer bought, when they visited or anything from your booking system, you are disclosing personal data in public. Keep those details for the private conversation. This article is general information, not legal advice.
How we help
Reviews, your profile and your website.
Replying well is one part of a strong local presence. The other parts are a complete, accurate Google profile, a steady flow of genuine reviews, and a website that says the same thing as the profile. We cover the profile side in 12 Google Business Profile fixes and the full service on SEO in Malta.
| Task | How it is often done | How we do it |
|---|---|---|
| Spotting new reviews | Noticed weeks later | New reviews checked as part of the monthly plan, so none sit unanswered |
| Replies | The same line pasted under every review | A short, specific draft for you to approve, in the reviewer’s language |
| Policy breaches | Everything reported, or nothing | Only clear breaches reported, with a note of why |
| Getting new reviews | Asking only happy customers, or offering a discount | A request you are allowed to send to everyone |
SEO plans start from €997 a month and include Google Business Profile work. If your profile sends people to a weak website, or to none, our websites start from €990. Malta Digital has 18 Google reviews of its own, and the same rules apply to us.
Want help with your Google reviews and profile? Apply now for SEO in Malta
A few straight answers
What you might be wondering.
Should I respond to negative Google reviews?
Yes, in most cases. Your reply is public, the reviewer is notified, and future customers read it. A short, honest reply that says what you changed can persuade the next reader and may lead the reviewer to update their review. Google says you do not need to reply to every review, but negative ones are where a reply helps most.
How do you respond to a negative Google review?
Thank the reviewer, own the part that was your fault, explain briefly without excuses, say what you changed, and invite them to contact your business privately. Sign with your name. Keep it to about five sentences and never share their private details.
Can I get a negative Google review removed?
Only if it breaks Google’s policies, for example if it is fake, from a competitor or a former employee, abusive, off-topic or contains personal information. Report it from your Business Profile. Google says it does not remove reviews just because a business disagrees with them.
How long does Google take to check a reported review?
Google says review evaluation typically takes several days. You can follow the status in the Reviews Management Tool. If Google finds no violation, you can submit a one-time appeal for up to 10 reviews.
Can I offer a discount to a customer who changes a bad review?
No. Google bans offering payment, discounts or free goods or services in exchange for posting, changing or removing a review, and removes reviews posted after such incentives. You can still refund an unhappy customer, as long as the refund is not tied to the review.
Are fake reviews illegal in Malta?
For businesses, yes. Malta’s Consumer Affairs Act, as amended by Act XIII of 2022, treats submitting or commissioning false consumer reviews to promote products, and claiming reviews are from real customers without reasonable checks, as unfair commercial practices.
What should I do if someone asks for money to remove bad reviews?
Do not reply, pay or offer anything. Take screenshots of every demand with dates and contact details, copy the links to the suspicious reviews, and send everything through Google’s merchant extortion report form. You can also report the demand to the Malta Police.
Sources
Where these facts come from.
- Google Business Profile Help: Manage customer reviews (read 10 November 2026)
- Google Business Profile Help: Tips to get more reviews, section “Tips to write better review replies” (read 10 November 2026)
- Google Business Profile Help: Report inappropriate reviews on your Business Profile (read 10 November 2026)
- Google Business Profile Help: Report negative review extortion scams (read 10 November 2026)
- Maps user-generated content policy: Prohibited and restricted content (read 10 November 2026)
- Guidelines for representing your business on Google (read 10 November 2026)
- Google Legal Help: Report content for legal reasons (read 10 November 2026)
- Act XIII of 2022 amending the Consumer Affairs Act (transposing Directive (EU) 2019/2161), new points 23b and 23c (read 10 November 2026)
- Media and Defamation Act, Cap. 579: arts. 3 and 9 (read 10 November 2026)
Keep reading
Related guides.
Google Business Profile optimisation: 12 fixes
Name, categories, service areas, photos and reviews.
Business not showing on Google Maps?
Causes and fixes when your profile is missing.
A useful first step
Ready for a Google profile that earns trust?
SEO plans from €997 a month, including Google Business Profile and review work. Websites from €990. Tell us about your business and we reply with what we would fix first.
Step 1 of 3
Apply now for SEO
A few quick questions. About 1 minute.